When it premiered at Sundance a 12 months in the past, We’re All Going to the World’s Honest couldn’t assist however seem like a mirror held as much as its viewers, reflecting again the isolation of the typical digital viewer. It helped to expertise this haunting microbudget temper piece months upon months into the pandemic, and thru a laptop computer display, the identical black gap that absorbs its teenage heroine. But the movie’s resonance inches past the perimeters of our specific second, previous the loneliness of the rapid now to the loneliness of the indefinite now. For so long as we’ve had the web, we’ve had motion pictures concerning the web. Is it too quickly, or too hyperbolic, to explain We’re All Going to the World’s Honest as some of the insightful of all of them?
Casey (Anna Cobb, outstanding in what the opening credit reveal is her function debut) lives in an unidentified stretch of nowhere America, a small-town wasteland of empty fields and abandoned Toys “R” Us parking heaps. We by no means see her mother and father, and solely hear them as soon as; bellowing for quiet at midnight and on the opposite aspect of a wall, they appear as distant from her as the man message-board trawlers and the YouTube artists she follows. Just like the equally named Kayla from Eighth Grade, the sunny yin to this movie’s doomy-macabre yang, Casey has no obvious buddies or social life. Not like Kayla, her important curiosity is creepypasta, that on-line group of horror folklorists and concrete legend fanatics.
Extra particularly, she’s drawn to a role-playing sport referred to as The World’s Honest, by which individuals utter a Candyman-like mantra into their gadgets, then creatively doc the supposed supernatural modifications their our bodies and minds bear. We first meet Casey as she’s becoming a member of the sport, by a webcam session that serves because the movie’s prolonged opening shot. After a false begin, she tidies up her bed room and dims the lights for higher ambiance, earlier than relaunching right into a séance of pinpricks, strobe gentle, and repeated incantation. Proper from the soar, the film foregrounds the query of the place efficiency ends and the actual Casey begins. It’s a line that may solely develop blurrier as she trudges additional into the pixelated unknown.
Jane Schoenbrun, the triple-threat author, director, and editor of We’re All Going to the World’s Honest, utterly immerses us in Casey’s searching habits—which, by the troubling logic of this mysterious first function, could be indistinguishable from her psychology. Lengthy stretches unfold from the vantage of the lady’s webcam, and Casey attracts readily on the visible language of horror for her vlogs, at one level executing a fairly chilling riff on the in a single day surveillance thrills of Paranormal Exercise. The construction, in the meantime, nearly suggests a tube channel, queuing up associated movies as the teenager toggles between her personal efficiency artwork and that of the opposite gamers in her feed. If this fictional character made a film about her life, it might most likely look lots like We’re All Going to the World’s Honest.
Is Casey actually being sucked into the hungry maw of the web, letting go of herself put up by put up? Or is she simply expertly taking her flip in a sport, cosplaying a slow-motion breakdown? Schoenbrun retains the questions hanging like storm clouds, with an important help from their spookily opaque star. Cobb has the off-the-cuff vulnerability of a budding internet movie star, expertly conveying the benefit of a era that’s grown up on digicam and the unease of somebody who could be shedding contact with actuality, disappearing below glow-in-the-dark make-up and outbursts of debatably feigned despair. Her greatest scenes flip the viewers into emotional detectives, sorting reality from artifice. Take, for instance, the second when Casey interrupts her personal TikTok-ready song-and-dance routine with a sudden bloodcurdling screaming jag. It’s transparently a pantomime of shattering sanity, an act. However Cobb lets us see the actual desperation effervescent beneath Casey’s imitation of the identical.
We’re All Going to the World’s Honest could be as unsettling, within the creeping psychological darkness of its materials, because the spooky style fare it resembles. It’s troublesome to observe the movie and never consider tales of real-life youngsters falling down YouTube rabbit holes of suicidal despair or taking a unsuitable flip into right-wing radicalization. Unfriended, one other of the few important movies about residing on-line within the twenty first century, used its ingenious laptop-vision gimmick to savage the best way some teenagers compartmentalize their darkish sides, by cyberbullying from the security of anonymity. World’s Honest, which borrows methods (however not the restrictions) of Screenlife and found-footage thrillers, arrives at a conclusion no extra comforting: For sure youngsters, there could also be no significant distinction between the “actual” them and who they’re on-line.
However We’re All Going to the World’s Honest is not any cautionary story for involved mother and father. Why sound an alarm a few world that’s already come to move? The tone is extra ambivalent, undercutting the anxiousness with optimism. It’s there in a DIY appreciation for this specific subculture of storytellers and the inventive victories of youngsters like Casey, a genuinely promising artist whether or not she considers herself one or not. (In an period when filmmakers nonetheless wrestle to make the interfaces of telephones and computer systems attention-grabbing to have a look at, right here’s a film that finds magnificence within the harsh digital textures of streaming video, and in faces illuminated by the flashing lights of a monitor.) There’s additionally the best way Schoenbrun, who’s non-binary, gives a metaphor for dysphoria within the mythology of their plot, operating a line of affect to a seminal instance of genre-bending web cinema, The Matrix. Because the movie underscores, not all transformations of id are damaging or dangerous.
Ultimately, Casey forges a reference to an older male participant, a deep voice behind a creepy avatar. An viewers’s first intuition could be protecting alarm—particularly when the actor, Michael J. Rogers, seems to be a useless ringer for Jackie Earle Haley. However right here, too, Schoenbrun resists simple solutions, proper as much as a staggeringly ambiguous ending. The implications are troubling however removed from apparent; the place one other filmmaker would possibly emphasize the hazard of reaching out into the digital abyss for a lifeline, this one solely laments the impossibility of it — the best way the pc display won’t ever really be permeable, irrespective of how a lot empathy we pour into it. The last word roleplay, the movie implies, is to fake you may really know somebody on-line.
We’re All Going to the World’s Honest opens in choose theaters April 15 and is offered to lease or buy on digital platforms April 22. For extra evaluations and writing by A.A. Dowd, go to his Authory web page.
Editors’ Suggestions
